Wholistic Rubric
4
Responds directly to the DBQ prompt.
Demonstrates critical evaluation and accurate analysis of multiple resources provided.
Argument is compelling, explained in detail, and supported with multiple sources of evidence.
Anticipates and refutes likely counter-arguments.
Includes a thesis statement and roadmap which give direction and purpose to the composition.
Organized from beginning to end - writing flows logically, includes smooth transitions between topics, an interesting lead and satisfying conclusion.
Author skillfully paraphrases, summarizes, and synthesizes information to create something new.
All documents are cited.
Voice is appropriate for audience.
Few errors do not interfere with meaning.
3
Responds directly to the DBQ prompt.
Demonstrates critical evaluation and accurate analysis of multiple resources provided.
Argument is sound, explained in detail, and supported with multiple sources of evidence.
Includes a thesis statement and roadmap which give direction and purpose to the composition.
Organized from beginning to end.
Author paraphrases, summarizes, and synthesizes information.
Most documents are cited.
Voice is appropriate for audience.
Some errors interfere with meaning in a limited way.
2
Responds directly to the DBQ prompt.
Demonstrates some understanding of the resources provided.
Argument is sound and supported with evidence but needs additional elaboration.
Includes a thesis statement.
Demonstrates basic organization.
Errors may interfere with meaning.
1
Shows confusion in terms of responding to the prompt.
Argumentation and evidence are limited.
Lacks organization.